R&D tax advisers need professional indemnity insurance that answers claims from clients who lose relief, repay credits or face extra costs because of how their claim was advised on or prepared. HMRC has found high levels of error in R&D claims, asks for every agent involved in a claim to be named, and from May 2026 requires paid tax advisers to register before dealing with it. Whether a policy covers R&D work, contingent fees and the losses that follow an HMRC enquiry depends on the policy wording, so check it against the work you actually do.

Need professional indemnity cover?Tell us about your work and a broker will look for cover that meets your professional body's terms.

What has HMRC found about R&D claims and the advisers behind them?

HMRC ran a random enquiry programme to measure error and fraud in R&D claims. For 2020 to 2021 it estimated error and fraud at 24.4% in the SME scheme and 3.6% in the RDEC scheme. Its later report put the SME figure for 2021 to 2022 at 25.8%, with RDEC at 4.6%, and gave lower illustrative estimates for 2022 to 2023 and 2023 to 2024.

Advisers are central to this. HMRC says more than 90% of claimants are represented by an agent, and that some agents give “poor or incorrect advice to customers about what they are entitled to claim”. It carried out 9,700 R&D compliance checks in 2023 to 2024, up from 8,300 the year before. HMRC does not regulate tax agents, but its powers include refusing to deal with an agent, suspending agent services accounts, publishing deliberate defaulters, dishonest conduct penalties and, where appropriate, criminal prosecution.

A client whose claim is cut back after a check may look to the adviser who prepared it. See HMRC R&D compliance checks.

Who may submit an R&D claim and who must be named?

A missed step can make a claim invalid, which is the kind of loss a client may try to recover from its adviser.

  • Claim notification. A company claiming for the first time, or whose last claim was more than three years earlier, must send a claim notification within six months after the end of the period of account. The form can be completed by a representative of the company or an agent acting on its behalf. If it is not sent, HMRC says the claim will be invalid. The rule applies to accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2023. HMRC’s guidance, updated on 29 October 2026, says a claim notification form is not needed for claims made on or after 1 April 2027.
  • Additional information form. Every new claim must be supported by an additional information form, sent before or on the same day as the CT600. It can be submitted by a representative of the company or by an agent through an agent services account. It must give contact details for all agents involved in the claim, including anyone who gave advice, analysed costs, helped with technical assessments or completed the forms or the CT600. Without it, HMRC says the claim will not be accepted, and if the return is filed first HMRC will remove the R&D claim.
  • Adviser registration. From 18 May 2026 paid tax advisers who deal with HMRC for clients must register under new rules, rolled out in stages until spring 2027. An adviser who misses their deadline or fails the standards will not be permitted to interact with HMRC on behalf of clients.

See claim notification and additional information rules.

Ask us for a quote

Tell us about your practice, your fee income, the work you do and your professional body, and we will look for professional indemnity cover for you. Call 01795 841 310 (Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm) or send us your details.

Ask for a quote

★★★★★ Rated 4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot from over 160 reviews

What kinds of claims do R&D advisers face?

Claims against R&D advisers commonly follow an HMRC check or a missed filing step. Allegations can include:

  • advising that activity qualified when it did not meet the definition of R&D, so relief or a payable credit has to be repaid;
  • including costs that did not qualify, such as overseas or subcontracted costs under the wrong rules;
  • missing the claim notification window, so the claim is invalid;
  • filing the return before the additional information form, so HMRC removes the claim;

The client’s loss may include repaid relief, interest, the cost of dealing with the enquiry and any penalty. Whether a policy pays for penalties, or treats repaid relief as a loss rather than money the client was never entitled to, depends on the policy wording and on the law. See how PI claims from tax advice tend to arise, and our accountants’ PII claims examples.

Need professional indemnity cover?Tell us about your work and a broker will look for cover that meets your professional body's terms.

What does the policy wording decide for R&D work?

Check these points before you accept a quote:

  • Description of your business. R&D claim preparation and technical reports should be named in the professional business you are insured for. Work outside that description may not be covered.
  • Fee basis. Some advisers charge a share of the relief obtained. Ask whether contingent fees, or claims for return of fees, are covered or excluded.
  • Specialists you use. If engineers, scientists or other firms write technical narratives for you, check that their work is covered when done on your behalf.
  • Dishonesty and fraud. A wording may deal separately with dishonest acts of staff and partners. Read how this one treats them.
  • Notification. Qualifying insurance under ICAEW rules covers claims first made, or circumstances notified, during the policy period, so an HMRC letter opening a check may be a circumstance you need to report. ICAEW’s guidance says insurers should be notified immediately of circumstances that might reasonably give rise to a claim, even if the allegations are vague.

What does your professional body require?

If you are an ICAEW member in public practice, its Professional Indemnity Insurance Regulations in force from 1 October 2026 set a minimum limit of £2 million for any single claim and in the aggregate. Where gross fee income is below £800,000, the minimum is two and a half times gross fee income, with a minimum of £250,000. The maximum aggregate excess is the higher of £3,000 or 3% of gross fee income. Gross fee income includes subcontracted work unless it is clearly a disbursement and the client knows the firm is not taking professional responsibility for it.

Members of other bodies should check their own rules. See minimum PII for accountants and our page on professional indemnity insurance for tax advisers. If you are not a member of any body, no professional body sets a minimum for you, but a client contract may.

Rule What it says Who sets it
Claim notification Within six months after the end of the period of account for first time claimants or those with no claim in three years HMRC
Who files the notification A representative of the company or an agent acting for it HMRC
Additional information form Needed for every new claim, sent before or with the CT600, naming all agents involved HMRC
Adviser registration From 18 May 2026 for paid advisers dealing with HMRC for clients HMRC
ICAEW minimum limit £2 million, or 2.5 times fee income with a £250,000 minimum where fee income is below £800,000 ICAEW
ICAEW maximum excess Higher of £3,000 or 3% of gross fee income ICAEW

What drives the premium for an R&D adviser?

We cannot quote a typical price, because insurers rate each firm on its own facts. The main drivers are:

  • the share of your fee income that comes from R&D work, and the total amount of relief your claims produce;
  • whether you charge fixed fees or a percentage of the relief;
  • how many clients are first time claimants;
  • who reviews the technical case and the costs before filing;
  • your claims and HMRC check history, and how checks were resolved;
  • the limit of indemnity and excess you choose.

What should you have ready when asking for a quote?

Have your fee income split by type of work, the number of R&D claims filed in the last year, your fee basis, your review process, details of any subcontracted technical writers, a full claims and circumstances history and a sample engagement letter; see limiting liability in engagement letters. Then ask us for a quote through professional indemnity insurance for accountants, or call 01795 841 310, Monday to Friday 9am to 5pm, and we will look for cover.

Example. A two person firm prepares an R&D claim for a software company. Two years later HMRC opens a check and decides most of the work was routine development. The company repays the credit and asks the firm to pay its losses. The firm reported the HMRC letter to its insurer when it arrived, so the claim is dealt with under the policy that was in force at that time, subject to its terms.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need separate PII for R&D work?

Not necessarily. Your main accountants’ policy may include R&D work if you declare it and it falls within the insured business description. Specialist R&D firms may be asked for more detail.

Can my client submit the additional information form instead of me?

Yes. HMRC accepts it from a representative of the company or an agent through an agent services account, but every agent involved in the claim must still be named.

What happens if I am not registered with HMRC as a tax adviser?

Under the rules starting 18 May 2026, an adviser who misses their deadline or fails the standards will not be permitted to deal with HMRC on behalf of clients.

Should I tell my insurer when HMRC opens a check on a client’s R&D claim?

Check your policy’s notification condition. ICAEW’s guidance says to notify immediately where circumstances might reasonably give rise to a claim, even if you think liability is unlikely.

Sources

Reviewed by Christine Anderson, Broker, Solar Protect. Last reviewed 16 November 2026. Solar Protect is the trading name of Solar Insurance Services (Medway) Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. This page is general information, not personal advice.