Being refused home insurance online or by a comparison site does not mean nobody will insure your home. It means your home or your circumstances fell outside that insurer’s rules. The next step is to find out why, answer every question accurately and approach insurers that look at non standard risks, often through a broker.
Looking for cover for this property?Tell us about it, including any subsidence, flooding or empty periods, and a broker will look for cover.
Why do insurers refuse home insurance?
Every insurer sets its own underwriting rules, which say which homes and people it will cover, on what terms and at what price. Online forms and comparison sites run your answers through those rules automatically, so one answer outside them can stop a quote before a person has looked at the detail. The Financial Ombudsman Service says that when an insurer relies on what it would have done with different information, its underwriting guide setting out what it would have done in certain situations is useful evidence. In other words, a refusal reflects that insurer’s rules, not a verdict on whether your home can be insured at all.
Answers that can trip automated rules include:
- non standard construction, a thatched or flat roof, or a timber frame (see non standard construction home insurance)
- previous claims, particularly subsidence, escape of water or flood (see home insurance with a subsidence history and home insurance after a flood claim)
- a home in a flood risk area
- a home that is empty, being renovated or part built (see unoccupied home insurance)
- unspent criminal convictions for anyone in the household
- business use, lodgers or an unusual letting arrangement
Whether any one of these leads to a refusal, extra terms or a higher price depends on the insurer and the policy wording. Even within the Flood Re scheme, Flood Re says the decision to use the scheme remains with the insurance provider.
Do I have to tell a new insurer I was refused before?
For a home you live in, the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 applies. It says it is the duty of the consumer to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation to the insurer. In practice that means answering the questions you are asked honestly and carefully. If the application asks whether you have ever been refused insurance, had a policy cancelled or had special terms applied, answer accurately, including a refusal from an online form if the question covers it.
The duty continues at renewal and when you change your policy. The Act says a failure to comply with an insurer’s request to confirm or amend details you gave before can count as a misrepresentation. So if your renewal invitation lists your details and asks you to check them, check them. The Financial Ombudsman Service says that if a customer is unsure of the answer to a question, it is reasonable to expect them to find out. Our page on answering home insurance questions goes through the common ones.
Ask us for a quote
Tell us about the property, including its construction, any claims, flooding or subsidence, and we will look for cover for you. Call 01795 841 310 (Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm) or send us your details.
★★★★★ Rated 4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot from over 160 reviews
What happens if I get an answer wrong?
The 2012 Act sets out what an insurer can do when a wrong answer was a qualifying misrepresentation, meaning it made a difference to the insurer’s decision. What the insurer can do depends on whether the mistake was deliberate or reckless, or careless.
| Type of wrong answer | What the insurer can do under the Act |
|---|---|
| Deliberate or reckless | Avoid the policy and refuse all claims, and keep the premiums unless that would be unfair |
| Careless, and the insurer would not have offered cover at all | Avoid the policy and refuse all claims, but return the premiums |
| Careless, and the insurer would have used different terms | Treat the policy as if it had those terms, such as an exclusion |
| Careless, and the insurer would have charged more | Reduce a claim in proportion to the premium you paid compared with what it would have charged |
The Financial Ombudsman Service says that if an insurer thinks a misrepresentation was deliberate or reckless, it needs to show why, and if the ombudsman is not satisfied it is likely to treat it as careless. One of its published cases shows how this works. A homeowner declared one earlier claim but not a second one, assuming it was more than five years old. It was still open. After a fire, the insurer cancelled the policy and turned down the claim, and the ombudsman did not uphold her complaint because she had not checked before answering and the insurer would not have offered cover if it had known.
Looking for cover for this property?Tell us about it, including any subsidence, flooding or empty periods, and a broker will look for cover.
What will a specialist insurer want to know?
Insurers that consider non standard homes want the full picture at the start. Having it ready saves time and avoids gaps that cause problems later. Expect to be asked for:
- details of every refusal, cancellation or special term, with the reason if you know it
- your claims history for the period the insurer asks about, with dates, causes, amounts and whether each claim is open or closed
- the construction of the walls and roof, the age of the property and whether it is listed
- any survey, structural engineer’s report or certificate of structural adequacy if there has been movement or repair work
- flood resistance or resilience work, and any flood history
- who lives in the home, whether it is ever empty and whether any part is let or used for business
- details of any unspent convictions, as asked
- a rebuild cost for the buildings and a realistic replacement value for the contents
What drives the price when cover is harder to find?
We cannot give typical prices because they vary so much with the property and the people living in it. What drives the price is the insurer’s view of how likely a claim is and how much it could cost. That includes the rebuild cost, the construction, the claims history, flood and subsidence exposure, security, how often the home is empty and the excess you choose. Accepting a higher excess, or an endorsement such as a condition to keep gutters clear or fit approved locks, can change what an insurer is willing to offer.
Insurance Premium Tax is added to the premium at the standard rate of 12%. Under the FCA pricing rules that took effect on 1 January 2022, a renewal price for home insurance must be no greater than the equivalent new business price, which is the price that insurer would charge a new customer for the same policy. That does not stop other insurers quoting less, so it is still worth comparing at renewal.
How can a broker help after a refusal?
Solar Protect is an FCA authorised insurance broker. When you ask us for a quote, we collect the details once, present the risk clearly and look for cover with insurers whose rules suit your home. We will explain any terms, exclusions or conditions before you buy. We cannot promise cover, and some situations take time to place, but a fully explained risk is easier to assess than a form that stops at the first unusual answer. Call us on 01795 841 310, Monday to Friday 9am to 5pm.
What if I think a refusal or cancellation was unfair?
Insurers decide which risks they accept, so a refusal to quote is a commercial decision for that insurer. If the problem is with an existing policy, such as a cancellation or a claim being turned down, complain to the insurer first. The Financial Ombudsman Service says you can bring the complaint to it if the insurer has not sent a final response within eight weeks, or if you are unhappy with its response. Our page on the Financial Ombudsman Service explains how that works.
Example. Priya owns a 1930s semi detached house. An online quote stopped when she said there had been a subsidence claim eight years ago. She contacted a broker with the claim reference, the engineer’s report and the certificate of structural adequacy from the repairs, along with her current claims record. The broker presented the file to insurers that consider past subsidence, and one offered cover with a higher subsidence excess. Priya read the terms and accepted.
Frequently asked questions
Does a comparison site saying no quotes are available count as being refused insurance?
It depends on how the next insurer words its question. Read it carefully. If you are unsure whether your experience falls within it, tell the insurer or broker what happened so they can decide. Guessing is where problems start.
How far back do I need to go when listing previous claims?
Go back as far as the question asks, and check the dates and status of each claim with your previous insurer rather than relying on memory. The ombudsman case above turned on a claim the customer wrongly assumed was outside the period.
Will having a specialist policy affect my mortgage?
Lenders set their own buildings insurance conditions, so check your mortgage offer. Tell us about any lender requirements when you ask for a quote so we can take them into account.
Can I get cover while my home is empty or being renovated?
Cover for a home that is empty or under major works depends on the policy wording, so tell the insurer. See our page on home insurance during building work.
Should I wait for a refusal to drop off my record before applying again?
No. Apply when you need cover and answer the questions as they are asked. An honest, complete application is the safest route to a policy that pays out.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: 2
- legislation.gov.uk: 1
- Financial Ombudsman Service: Misrep and non disclosure
- Financial Ombudsman Service: Misrepresentation non disclosure
- Financial Ombudsman Service: Insurer voided home insurance policy refused claim fire damage
- www.floodre.co.uk: General
- GOV.UK: Insurance premium tax
- FCA: Ep25 2
Reviewed by Christine Anderson, Broker, Solar Protect. Last reviewed 18 November 2026. Solar Protect is the trading name of Solar Insurance Services (Medway) Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. This page is general information, not personal advice.
