When an employee receives shares free or at a discount because of their job, the market value of the shares less anything they pay is taxed as earnings under section 62 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 at the time they acquire them. If the shares are readily convertible assets, the employer must collect the tax through PAYE and pay employee and employer Class 1 National Insurance; if not, there is normally no Class 1 and the employee pays through Self Assessment. Restrictions on the shares, deferred payment terms and tax advantaged plans change the answer, and every award must be reported on the employer’s annual employment related securities return.
Tax investigation insurance from £117.62 a year (£9.80 a month).Pays up to £100,000 of your accountant's fees if HMRC opens an enquiry. No excess. Buy online in a few minutes.
Why is a gift of shares taxed when no cash changes hands?
Section 62(2)(b) ITEPA 2003 defines earnings to include any gratuity, profit or incidental benefit obtained by the employee if it is money or money’s worth, meaning something of direct monetary value or capable of being converted into it. HMRC’s Employment Related Securities Manual at ERSM20500 says that whenever an employee acquires a security from their employment free or for less than its market value there is a charge, because shares can be sold for their value. The courts settled this long ago. In Weight v Salmon a managing director allowed to buy shares at par was taxed on the difference between their market value and what he paid, even though he never sold them (ERSM20510). In Ede v Wilson, a restriction on selling the shares did not stop them being earnings; it only affected their value (ERSM20520).
ERSM20500 gives a worked example. An employee joining a new company subscribes for 5,000 ordinary 25p shares at par when each is worth £1.87. The market value is £9,350, she pays £1,250, and the £8,100 difference is taxed as earnings.
Which shares are treated as acquired because of employment?
The wider regime in Part 7 ITEPA 2003 covers shares acquired by reason of employment. Under section 421B(3), if the right or opportunity to acquire the shares is made available by the employer or a person connected with the employer, it is deemed to be by reason of employment (ERSM20210). ERSM20010 confirms this includes shares acquired by directors or employees on the formation of a company. If shares meant for an employee are issued to someone else at their request, the employee is still the one taxed.
The only exception is where an individual makes the shares available in the normal course of domestic, family or personal relationships. ERSM20220 gives the example of a father handing his family company shares to his son and daughter on retirement simply because they are his children. It is a question of fact: if many staff receive shares and the owner’s children are among them, the employment is likely to be the reason. For a wider introduction see employment related securities basics.
Worried about an HMRC check? Tax investigation insurance pays your accountant’s fees if HMRC opens an enquiry or compliance check. Solar Protect cover pays up to £100,000 with no excess. It never pays tax, interest or penalties.
From £117.62 a year (£9.80 a month) for individuals, £127.33 for sole traders and £226.25 for companies and partnerships, including IPT and the £20 admin fee.
See my price in 2 questions or call 01795 841 310.
★★★★★ Rated 4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot from over 160 reviews
How is the taxable amount worked out?
The starting point is the market value of the shares when the benefit is provided (ERSM20540), less anything the employee pays. Market value for unquoted shares has a specific meaning, explained in our guide to valuing shares for employee schemes. Three common variations change the figure:
- Restricted shares. Under section 425(2), if the shares can be forfeited and the forfeiture restriction will lift within 5 years, there is no charge on acquisition; tax arises later when restrictions lift (ERSM30370). Employer and employee can elect under section 425(3) within 14 days of acquisition to be taxed on the restricted value now instead. For other restricted shares the charge is on their actual, restricted value, with a further charge when restrictions lift, unless a section 431 election is made to pay tax on the full unrestricted value at the outset.
- Deferred or unpaid consideration. Where the employee pays less than market value at acquisition and owes the balance, as with partly paid shares or a price left outstanding, Chapter 3C (section 446Q) treats the shortfall as a notional interest free loan (ERSM70010 and ERSM70020). There is an annual beneficial loan charge, reported on the P11D, with Class 1A National Insurance on the same amount, and a further charge with Class 1 when the obligation is released.
- Options. A right to acquire shares later is a securities option, taxed under the rules for unapproved share options rather than as an immediate gift (ERSM20540).
Tax investigation insurance from £117.62 a year (£9.80 a month).Pays up to £100,000 of your accountant's fees if HMRC opens an enquiry. No excess. Buy online in a few minutes.
When does the employer run PAYE and National Insurance?
ERSM170020 sets out the test. PAYE applies if the shares are a readily convertible asset under section 702, for example because they are quoted or trading arrangements exist. It also applies if they are not readily convertible but are not shares qualifying for corporation tax relief under Part 12 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009. In either case the employer accounts for PAYE on its best estimate of the taxable amount (ERSM170050). The detail of the definition is in our guide to readily convertible assets.
For National Insurance, ERSM170700 explains that a payment in kind is normally disregarded for Class 1, but a payment by way of a readily convertible asset is not. So readily convertible shares carry employee and employer Class 1 contributions, while shares that are not readily convertible normally carry no Class 1 on acquisition and the employee reports the income through Self Assessment.
Because there is no cash wage to deduct from, the employee must make good the PAYE the employer could not deduct within 90 days after the end of the tax year. If not, section 222 treats the shortfall as further income. ERSM170400 gives the example of an award on 28 February, where the employee has until 4 July.
What must be reported to HMRC?
Section 421J requires information about any acquisition of shares by reason of employment, whether or not tax arises, to be given on the online employment related securities return. HMRC’s guide 480 (chapter 23) says it must be filed before 7 July following the tax year of the event. Under section 421L the employer, any host employer, the person transferring the shares and the issuing company are all responsible, but one return satisfies them all. Where a notional loan arises, it also goes on the P11D each year until it is discharged.
Can shares be given without an income tax charge?
Yes, through a tax advantaged scheme. HMRC’s guide to employee share schemes says an employer can give up to £3,600 of free shares in a tax year through a Share Incentive Plan, and shares kept in the plan for 5 years are free of Income Tax and National Insurance. Options under a Company Share Option Plan, SAYE or EMI can also avoid the charge on the discount if their conditions are met. Outside those schemes, the family relationship exception and genuinely paying full market value are the only routes to no charge.
What does the company get, and where do people go wrong?
ERSM20030 explains that the employer’s corporation tax relief is designed to arise when the employee is taxed, in the same amount; see corporation tax relief for employee shares.
Illustration only. An unquoted trading company gives a key employee 1,000 shares worth £5 each and she pays nothing. The shares are not readily convertible and qualify for corporation tax relief, so no PAYE or Class 1 is due. She has £5,000 of earnings to report on her Self Assessment return, and the company files the award on its return by 6 July after the tax year. Had the company been listed, the same £5,000 would go through payroll with PAYE and Class 1.
Common mistakes:
- Assuming founder or sweat equity shares are outside the rules because they were issued at formation.
- Using par value instead of market value.
- Missing the 14 day deadline for a section 425 or section 431 election.
- Forgetting the employment related securities return when no tax was due.
- Not collecting the PAYE from the employee within 90 days, creating a second charge under section 222.
If HMRC opens a check into your return, tax investigation insurance pays your accountant’s fees. Solar Protect cover pays up to £100,000 with no excess; it never pays tax, interest or penalties. Read how our cover works or get a quote.
Related Accountapedia entries
- Growth shares for employees
- NI on share option gains and NIC elections
- Phantom share schemes
- Employer paying an employee’s personal bills
- Employee benefit trusts: tax treatment
Related cover: Employers liability insurance: the legal requirements and Employers liability vs public liability.
Sources
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20500
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20510
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20520
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20210
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20010
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20220
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM20540
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM30370
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM70010
- GOV.UK: Manual page ERSM70020
Reviewed by Christine Anderson, Broker, Solar Protect. Last reviewed 19 October 2026. Part of Accountapedia, the Solar Protect guide to UK tax and accounting. This page is general information, not personalised advice.
