An accountant can apologise, explain what went wrong and put the work right, but should not accept legal liability, promise compensation or agree a settlement without the insurer’s written consent. The ICAEW, ICAS and Chartered Accountants Ireland minimum policy wording makes this a condition of cover, and treats a complaint as a claim, so the safest order is: assess the complaint, notify the insurer if it could lead to a claim, then respond on the insurer’s advice.

Tax investigation insurance from £117.62 a year (£9.80 a month).Pays up to £100,000 of your accountant's fees if HMRC opens an enquiry. No excess. Buy online in a few minutes.

What does a PI policy actually say about admitting liability?

Most firms in the chartered bodies buy cover based on the minimum approved policy wording shared by ICAEW, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland and Chartered Accountants Ireland. ICAEW’s PII Regulations require qualifying insurance to come from a participating insurer on terms that match that wording. Clause C5.1 of the wording says the insured shall:

  • not admit liability for, or settle, any claim without the written consent of insurers, such consent not to be unreasonably withheld or unreasonably delayed; and
  • not incur any defence costs without the written consent of insurers, on the same basis.

Clause C5.2 gives insurers the right to take over the defence, investigation or settlement of any claim, and to investigate notified circumstances, and entitles them to the full cooperation of the insured. Clause C2 requires written notice of any claim, and of any circumstance that may give rise to a claim, as soon as reasonably practicable. Policies bought by members of other bodies use market wordings, so read your own conditions section: the admissions clause is usually headed “conduct of claims” or similar.

Does a client complaint count as a claim?

Under the minimum wording it can. Clause B3 defines a claim as any written or oral demand for compensation or damages from, or the assertion of a right against, any insured, and it expressly includes any complaint or reference to an ombudsman. Insuring clause A2 also covers amounts an ombudsman requires the insured to pay. So a client who says “you got this wrong and I want my money back” may already have made a claim, and the conduct of claims condition then applies to everything the firm says next.

A complaint that is purely about service, such as slow replies, may never become a claim. ICAEW’s guidance on the duty to investigate complaints says firms must assess every complaint when it is lodged and, if it has the potential for a claim, notify the insurer or broker immediately. It also says that, once a complaint has been referred to insurers, the firm must follow the insurer’s advice so that cover is not affected.

Run an accountancy or bookkeeping practice? Solar Protect runs fee protection schemes for practices, so the cost of dealing with an HMRC enquiry into a client is covered rather than written off.

See how our accountant schemes work or call 01795 841 310.

Can I still apologise to the client?

Yes. An apology for the inconvenience, delay or worry the client has suffered is not the same as accepting that the firm owes damages. In England and Wales, section 2 of the Compensation Act 2006 says that an apology, an offer of treatment or other redress shall not of itself amount to an admission of negligence or breach of statutory duty. In Scotland, section 1 of the Apologies (Scotland) Act 2016 says an apology made outside civil proceedings is not admissible as evidence of anything relevant to liability and cannot be used to the prejudice of the person who made it.

Those protections cover the apology itself, not everything said alongside it. A sentence such as “we are sorry, this was our negligence and we will pay the penalty” goes well beyond an apology. It concedes breach of duty and offers a settlement, which is exactly what clause C5.1 prohibits without consent. Compare “we are sorry this has happened and we are looking into it urgently”, which tells the client you are taking it seriously without deciding liability.

Tax investigation insurance from £117.62 a year (£9.80 a month).Pays up to £100,000 of your accountant's fees if HMRC opens an enquiry. No excess. Buy online in a few minutes.

What does ICAEW expect when a client complains?

Professional rules still require the firm to engage. Under the ICAEW bye laws, as summarised in its complaints guidance, a firm must tell new clients in writing which principal to contact about a complaint and of their right to complain to ICAEW; must have any complaint about its services investigated immediately by a principal; and, if the complaint is justified in whole or part, must do whatever is appropriate to resolve it, whether by remedial work, apology, information, return of documents, reduction or repayment of fees, or otherwise.

The two duties fit together. The guidance says that where the client has not received the standard of service they should reasonably expect and there is any possibility of a claim for damages, the firm should consult its PII insurer; in other cases it should be frank and open, and apologise or offer to make amends. Where the firm concludes a complaint is not a potential insurance claim, any concession should be accompanied by wording such as “As a gesture of goodwill, and without admission of liability, we are prepared to…”. Clause C5.3 of the minimum wording also says that complying with the rules, requirements, directions or guidance of a regulator or ombudsman, where evidenced, will not breach any clause of the policy. For the procedural side of complaints, see our guide to client complaints procedures.

How should the firm respond without breaching the condition?

  1. Acknowledge promptly. Thank the client, confirm who is dealing with it and give a date for a fuller reply. Do not debate fault in the first response.
  2. Investigate. A principal not involved in the work should pull the file, the engagement letter and the correspondence, and establish what happened and what loss, if any, has been or may be suffered.
  3. Decide whether it could become a claim. If the client alleges loss, mentions compensation or lawyers, or the error could cause a penalty, interest or lost relief, notify the insurer or broker in writing with the facts.
  4. Fix what can be fixed, with consent where needed. Correcting a return, making a protective claim or contacting HMRC to limit a penalty is often in everyone’s interest, and insurers usually support prompt remedial work. Agree it with them first if the cost is significant or the steps could affect liability.
  5. Write carefully. Explain the facts and what is being done. Apologise for the position the client is in. Do not describe the work as negligent, do not promise to pay, and do not offer fee refunds as compensation for loss without consent.
  6. Keep the file intact. Preserve all records and route communication about the complaint through one person.

ICAEW technical release TECH 09/15BL makes the same point at a higher level: firms should have procedures to handle allegations and complaints, deal with claims promptly, notify insurers and take legal advice. Common sources of these complaints are covered in negligence claims against accountants.

What happens if the firm admits liability anyway?

Under the minimum wording, clause D2 deals with breach of policy conditions. Where the insured’s breach of a condition has prejudiced insurers in handling or settling a claim, and the indemnity is payable direct to the claimant, insurers will pay the indemnity in full and the insured must reimburse insurers for any amount that would not have been payable without that prejudice. The firm can end up funding the difference itself, on top of its excess. Under a different wording the consequences may be harsher, so check the policy rather than assuming the same outcome.

An unauthorised admission can also affect renewal. A firm that has to tell its next insurer it settled a claim without consent is unlikely to get the best terms, and the duty of fair presentation at renewal covers claims and circumstances. See fair presentation under the Insurance Act 2015.

How might this look in practice?

Illustration only. A client emails to say HMRC has charged a late filing penalty and interest because their partnership return was submitted late, and asks the firm to pay. The partner can see the return was ready but not filed after the client approved it.

  • Poor response: “So sorry, completely our fault, we will cover the penalty and interest.” That admits liability and agrees a settlement without consent.
  • Better response: “I am sorry you have received this. I am reviewing what happened and will come back to you by Friday. In the meantime we will check whether there are grounds to appeal the penalty.” The partner then notifies the insurer or broker, explains the facts, and asks whether insurers consent to the firm paying the penalty or appealing it.

The amounts may be small enough that the insurer is content for the firm to deal with it within the excess. The point is that the insurer decides that, not the partner, and the decision is recorded.

What mistakes do firms make?

  • Treating a complaint as “just a complaint” when the client has asked for money, which under the minimum wording is already a claim.
  • Offering a fee refund described as compensation. A goodwill gesture made without admission of liability is different from settling a loss.
  • Waiting until the client instructs solicitors before telling the insurer, even though notice is required as soon as reasonably practicable.
  • Letting the partner who did the work handle the complaint alone and write an emotional admission.
  • Forgetting that a circumstance not notified before the policy period ends may fall on a later policy with different terms or a higher excess.

Background on cover itself is in our guides to professional indemnity insurance for accountants and limitation periods for claims.

Solar Protect runs fee protection schemes for accountancy and bookkeeping practices. See how our accountant schemes work or read fee protection schemes for accountants.

Related Accountapedia entries


Related cover: Professional indemnity insurance for accountants and What professional indemnity insurance covers. For the whole practice, see insurance for accountants and fee protection schemes for your clients.

Sources

Reviewed by Christine Anderson, Broker, Solar Protect. Last reviewed 19 October 2026. Part of Accountapedia, the Solar Protect guide to UK tax and accounting. This page is general information, not personalised advice.